But both Jay and Jenn say he left her house between 3:30 p.m. and 3:45 p.m. In their closing statement, the prosecution contends that this was the 2:36 p.m. incoming call. According to Susan Simpson, another lawyer working on the Undisclosed podcast, the official recorded interviews between Wilds and the police reveal some strange auditory clues to why the police would lie about the date they began questioning Wilds. The story Jay told police had problems, because it kept changing from telling to telling, Koenig says in the first episode of Serial. But they were able to bolster the main plot points using cell records from Adnans phone., Others think the inconsistencies point toward something else Chaudry says in the documentary that she thinks the police were helping [Wilds] craft the story.. March 19, 2003:Syed unsuccessfully appealed his conviction. (That Gutierrez was disbarred in 2001 prior to her 2004 death lends further credence to this.). Timeline of Events Jan. 13, 1999: Hae Min Lee was reported missing when she didn't pick up her. Thats led to some wild and totally unproven ideas on reddit, notably that Adnan hired Jay as a kind of hitman. For instance, during one of his police interviews highlighted in The Case Against Adnan Syed,an officer asks Wilds, Youre sure its the 13th because we told you got these calls on the 13th? Jay responds in the affirmative. Adnan and Jay arrive at Leakin Park, and Adnan buries Haes body in the woods. The most plausible theory is that Wilds was more involved in the murder than he admitted, helping Syed both commit and cover it up, and that he confessed to a lesser crime to avoid punishment. In court, the prosecutor asks Jay to look at the 12:07 p.m. call to Jenns house. May 28, 2010:Syed made an appeal for post-conviction relief in 2010 based on ineffective assistance of counsel based on his defense attorney Cristina Gutierrez's failure to investigate an alibi witness, Asia McClain, who maintained she was talking with Syed in the library at the exact time that prosecutors said Syed attacked Lee in a Best Buy parking lot several miles away. Early February, 2016:The post-conviction relief hearing lasted five days. Jay goes to Jenns house and hangs out there for about three hours. If you can make head or tails of this latest swerve in the Serial universe, let us know. Three days later, Baltimore Police, For instance, during one of his police interviews highlighted in The Case Against Adnan Syed,an officer asks Wilds, Youre sure its the 13, The whole Jay storywas so confusing. March 8, 2019:In a split 43 ruling, the Court of Appeals reversed the findings of the lower courts, denying Syed's request for a new trial, court records show. Adnan goes to the Woodlawn Public Library to check his email. There are other legal options and we are exploring each and every one of them. Family friend and lawyer Chaudry added: He is hanging in there. Then they go back to the dumpster at Westview Mall and he wipes his fingerprints off the shovels. Jay calls his friend Patrick to score some weed. Who Was Mallory Beach in 'Murdaugh Murders'? Adnan throws some of Haes things into a dumpster at Westview Mall and Jay throws the shovels into a dumpster behind Value City. Jay Wilds has changed his story about what happened the day of Lee's murder multiple times . Jay Wilds Is a Lying Liar Who's Lies Destroyed Hundreds of Lives Jay lies. He was sentenced to life in prison plus 30 years. From conviction to freedom: A timeline of the Adnan Syed case, A legal expert discusses what's next for Adnan Syed, Recapping the important events leading up to Adnan Syed's release from prison, first season of the popular "Serial" podcast, Prosecutors dropped the charges of Adnan Syed. Though Wilds stands by his storyat least the one he told The InterceptChaudry and Undisclosed have continued to dig up evidence that wouldnt just exonerate Syed, but also Wilds himself. The cell tower that originates these calls covers Leakin Park. He spoke with The Intercept's Natasha Vargas-Cooper about his version of events on the day Baltimore-area teenager Hae Min Lee was killed in 1999. In this scenario, Wilds did not want his girlfriend Stephanie to know about it. He has a great legal team. "Why did they sit on this information? Many details of Jays story went unproven and yet Adnan Syed was sentenced to life in prison. They stay there 20-30 minutes. But Wilds, who is not heard from outside of taped testimony in either Serial or the HBO documentary, stood by what he told police in a three-part interview with The Intercept in 2014 following the podcast airing. In spite of this, Syeds attorney Cristina Gutierrez never interviewed her, and much of the push for a new trial hinges on the argument that she handled the case poorly. Syed's family, that day, fired his defense attorney. I wake up as soon as they put it on, he said. The state lied. Though Wilds didnt participate in Serial, he did conduct a .css-16acfp5{-webkit-text-decoration:underline;text-decoration:underline;text-decoration-thickness:0.125rem;text-decoration-color:#d2232e;text-underline-offset:0.25rem;color:inherit;-webkit-transition:all 0.3s ease-in-out;transition:all 0.3s ease-in-out;}.css-16acfp5:hover{color:#000;text-decoration-color:border-link-body-hover;background-color:yellow;-webkit-transition:all 0.3s ease-in-out;transition:all 0.3s ease-in-out;}three-part interview with The Intercepts Natasha Vargas-Cooper, and attorney Rabia Chaudry (also Syeds childhood friend) launched the Undisclosed podcast, both of which add layers to the mystery enshrouding Wilds testimony. Jay says Adnan called the cell phone right before he and Jenns brother left for the mall. Our product picks are editor-tested, expert-approved. Below are a few of the most prominent, with a few wild possibilities thrown in for good measure, presented with the caveat that in a case this fluidand with a case so discussed and analyzedthe facts starts to look blurrier and blurrier the closer you look at them. Another time, he claimed that Adnan had actually killed Hae at Patapsco State Park. This content is imported from twitter. All contents 2023 The Slate Group LLC. Olivia Fougeirol/HBO. Oxygen Insider is your all-access pass to never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and much more. Serials final first-season episode throws it out as a possibility in its final episode, a late-in-the-game twist after a season in which Koenig had uncovered many clues that Syed might not be guilty but had failed to offer any kind of opposing theory. Patapsco State Park is about a 20-minute drive from the Park and Ride and from Woodlawn High School. Adnan calls Jay on the cell phone and asks Jay to pick him up from track practice. Obviously Adnan and Jay have different memories of Jan. 13, 1999. Syed has maintained his innocence during his decades in prison, yet a 2019 attempt to hear an appeal for a new trial was turned down by the Supreme Court. The Intercept interviews Jay at length for the first time. She takes him to the F&M and he throws his clothes in a dumpster. He refused to speak to Koenig for the podcast, so this was a shocking development in the case. Following a rare 2014 interview with Natasha Vargas-Cooper of The Intercept, the outlet reported that Jay lived with his wife and children in a 'two-story suburban home.'. Lee died by manual strangulation. That was until Serial garnered worldwide attention and thrust the spotlight onto him and the holes in his various versions of events. Baltimore police were already focusing their investigation on Syed after an anonymous tip told them to look at Lees ex. Adnan arrives at Jays house. Jan. 13, 1999:Hae Min Lee was reported missing when she didn't pick up her younger cousin from daycare. Here, we piece together the accounts as they reportedly happened in the 1999 teen murder case: While their relationship was kept a secret because of both religious and cultural differences, classmates Syed and Lee dated in 1998, and broke up in December of that year, according to court records. Like all theories about the murder, the Syed Is Guilty theory hinges on what happened in the time between the end of the school day at 2:15 and Lees failure to make her 3:15 appointment. Redditors have already pounced on seeming inconsistencies and highlighted new twists; for instance, Wilds now says he first saw Lees body not in front of Best Buy, but outside of his grandmothers house. What happened on this particular day depends on who you talk to. And I looked real good again, and thats when I seen what looked like a foot. He later becomes a suspect because he walked 127 feet to find a place to use the restroom. It wasnt until they made it clear they werent interested in my procurement of pot that I began to open up any, Jay told Natasha Vargas-Cooper. Officer Adcock calls Adnan looking for Hae. According to Jay, he didnt tell this version before as he didnt want to involve his grandmother. Could he have gotten mixed up in heavier stuff at some point? Thats probably the most that Adnan and Jay agree on. Baltimore City State's Attorney Marilyn Mosby said Wednesday her office is seeking a new trial after a nearly-year long investigation revealed two new possible suspects. Adnan calls Jay on the cell phone and asks Jay to pick him up from practice. Mosby said to Hellgren. | Unsurprisingly, in the absence of an airtight answer, Serial listeners, amateur sleuths, and Reddit habitus have come up with theories of their own. browser that We are deeply disappointed by the Supreme Court, but by no means is this the end of Adnan Syed, attorney C. Justin Brown told AP at the time. Adnan calls Jay and tells Jay to meet him at a strip off Edmondson Ave. At the meeting point off Edmondson Ave., Adnan shows Jay Haes body in the trunk of her car. he goes to his photography and English classes and then calls his friend Jay Wilds, offering to lend him his car during his lunch . He failed; he lost the girl.. Syeds conviction for the murder of Hae Min Lee was the subject of the This American Life spinoff podcast Serial, hosted by Sarah Koenig, which aired this fall. Syeds first appeal is denied by the Court of Special Appeals, according to court records. Jay says Adnan called him after they got back from shopping, to see if the cell phone was turned on. Then he drives back to his house, and then to Cathys house to smoke weed there for another 10-20 minutes. Much of the attention came after the case became the subject of the This American Life podcast Serial in 2014. She found troubling inconsistencies, unanswered questions, and rich milieu in which teens from different backgrounds lived secret lives unimagined by their immigrant parents. But what we were pointing out in our story was that the timeline of the case and the evidence in the case had serious problems. This came after the 41-year-old served more than 23 years in prison. In the wee hours of the night, Lees car is found around 4:30 a.m. and around 6 a.m., Syed is arrested at his home on the 7000 block of Johnnycake Road. So if Syed didnt do it, who did? Baltimore City Circuit Court judge Melissa M. Phinn vacated Syed's conviction, effectively setting him free. In court, Jay identifies these calls as occurring at 3:48 p.m. and 3:59 p.m. Jay says they were driving on Forest Park Ave. at the time, which is an area that isnt covered by the cell tower that originates this call, L651A. Jay all but admitted to @BobRuffTruth that he got the reward. Adnan and Jay ditch Haes car at the I-70 Park and Ride. Serial is a podcast from the creators of This American Life. It's not that hard to squeeze Wilds into the timeline, . Wilds admitted he was involved with the cover-up, but what if he was the culprit? Has conversation with Asia. Autopsy results later show that Lee was strangled, The Baltimore Sun reports. And detective notes capped Browns interview with the word REWARD, written in all caps. Adnan arrives at Jays house. get Jay Wilds to talk on the record about the murder of Hae Min Lee, which Jay swore in court was the work of Hae's ex-boyfriend . Adnan calls Jay and offers to lend him his car. Adnan calls again on the cell phone and asks Jay to pick him up at 3:45 p.m. Jay doesnt hear from Adnan, so he leaves Jenns house to go to his friend Jeffs. That ruling has been subsequently appealed and upheld, and appealed again. No one is quite sure what they are, but the timing of the taps on the recording seems suspicious. Don's manager had confirmed to the cops he was at work that day. Some days Ill be like, This is a really great episode, and some days Ill feel down and depressed., February 6, 2015: Syed can appeal the post-conviction relief denial. What if it was a two-man job? The police call Adnan while theyre eating, looking for Hae. Jay and Adnan go to McDonalds. His case was featured on the first season of "Serial." Here is a brief timeline of events related to the death of Hae Min Lee. Check out never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and much more! Until 11 p.m., we don't have any more time references, we only know the order of events. He was the homecoming king and played on the varsity football team and worked part-time for a paramedic service. Wilds' shaky testimony was first highlighted in Serial, the 2014 podcast hosted by Sarah Koenig that brought Syeds case back into the public eye. After learning the jury had overheard this discussion, the judge granted Gutierrez's motion for a mistrial. We've finally heard from Jay Wilds, the key witness in the murder of Hae . Dont know how to get a podcast? The judge said the letters McClain sent Syed in jail were weak and possibly damaging evidence for the defense, since they did not state the time she saw him at the library and contradicted Syed's own account from that day.". Jay Wilds killed Hae Min Lee. Link your TV provider to stream full episodes and live TV. Patrick isnt home, so they head to Forest Park to buy it. February 12, 1999: Anonymous calls inform the police to look into Syed. She also found, in Syed, a charismatic subject who seemed like an unlikely murderer. They go to Westview Mall and Adnan tells Jay that hes going to kill Hae. Adnan gets in Haes car and tells Jay to wait for him at McDonalds. "My brother didn't believe my mom, so when I grabbed the phone and I told him, he was so happy. In court, the prosecution asks Jay about a phone call made from Adnans cell phone to Jenns house at 3:21 p.m. Jay testifies that he was calling Jenn to find out if she knew if Patrick was at home. Adnan goes home, picks up food to take to his father at the mosque. ", March 29, 2018:According to court records, the Maryland Court of Special Appeals upheld Syed's request for a new trial. A former Baltimore Sun reporter whod since moved onto to NPR, she became interested in the case after receiving an email from Baltimore lawyer Rabia Chaudry. Judge Wanda K. Heard gives Syed a life sentence plus 30 years. Feb. 9, 2015:Syed's family spoke out on the "Serial" podcast after the Maryland Court of Special Appeals decided to review the murder conviction. March 10, 2019. Even though he and Syed were allegedlyjust acquaintances, Wilds police interviews and witness testimony would ultimately be key to convicting Syed despite his storys inconsistencies and contradictions. When the Serial podcast premiered in October of 2014, many listeners were shocked to find that almost the entirety of the prosecutions case to convict Adnan Syed for the murder of his ex-girlfriend Hae Min Lee hinged on the testimony of one witnessJay Wilds. QUICK FACTS Birth Year: 1981 Birth date: May 21, 1981 Birth State: Maryland Birth. On February 9th, a man whos been publicly identified only as Mr. supports HTML5 1:30 p.m. Jenn comes home from work. The state prosecutor was referring to Jays account that Adnan strangled Hae to death and showed him the body which he helped bury. Syed has seen his conviction .css-16acfp5{-webkit-text-decoration:underline;text-decoration:underline;text-decoration-thickness:0.125rem;text-decoration-color:#d2232e;text-underline-offset:0.25rem;color:inherit;-webkit-transition:all 0.3s ease-in-out;transition:all 0.3s ease-in-out;}.css-16acfp5:hover{color:#000;text-decoration-color:border-link-body-hover;background-color:yellow;-webkit-transition:all 0.3s ease-in-out;transition:all 0.3s ease-in-out;}vacated due to ineffective counsel (more on that below). March 25, 2000: McClain writes an affidavit. Jay Wilds, the state's key witness in Adnan Syed's case for the murder of Hae Min Lee, has told many different accounts of the crime. Tom Cruise cried during Val Kilmer's Top Gun scene, See Sam Elliott's Rare Appearance at SAG Awards, 30 Netflix Original Movies Actually Worth Watching, You Must Watch Tr Before the 2023 Oscars. The trial begins the second week of December and quickly ends as a mistrial, the court appeals papers say. Many of the details he. Evening prayers at the mosque, according to Adnans fathers testimony. Which brings us back to the question at the heart of the matter: Who killed Hae Min Lee? January 1, 1999: Lee and Don Clinedinst go on their first date. And perhaps Syed was actually in possession of his cell phone for much of the day? Jay says it takes Adnan about a half an hour. He also claimedthat he felt like Koenig, whose account challenges his, tried to pressure him into giving an interview and created an evil archetype of him. He gets a call from Syed around 10:45 a.m. on Jan. 13; an hour later, Syed arrives at Wilds' house in his car and they both go to Baltimore's Westview Mall, where Syed tells Wilds he's going to kill Hae because he's angry about their breakup; at 12:30 p.m., Wilds drops off Syed at school and keeps his car; at 3:40 p.m., Syed tells Wilds to meet To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web As Jay is turning off Jeffs street, Adnan calls Jay and asks him to get him at Best Buy. The way Wilds tells it, Syed pressured him to help dispose of Lees body. And Jay's attorney from that time told me in an email that the prosecutor had threatened him, a black kid, with prosecuting him in Balt county, a white county & with the death penalty. 2023 CBS Broadcasting Inc. All Rights Reserved. But like so many theories around the case its just intriguing enough to warrant further investigation. He was just laughing," said Syed's brother, Yusuf Syed. Adnan calls Jay when Jay is halfway home to say Come and get me, Im at Best Buy.. He characterizes Adnan as a little pompous, a little arrogant really driven as far as academics more uptight than the other Muslim kids that I knew. He and Adnan werent close, he says, echoing Syeds own account of their relationship: There was never a real friendship. He remembers Lee, meanwhile, as independent and mature. Though Wilds tells Vargas-Cooper it isnt his job to speculate on Syeds motives, he cant help doing so a little bit anyway, positing that the man he helped convict just couldnt come to grips with being a loser and failing. Jay drives to Gilston Park to smoke a blunt by himself. It's been a long road from conviction to freedom for Syed. Jay goes to Jenns house. Feb. 6, 2015:The Maryland Court of Special Appeals approved Syed's application for permission to appeal for a potential hearing on the admissibility of the alibi testimony of Asia McClain. The Case Against Adnan Syed (2019) | Official Trailer | HBO, Fans Deserve a Second Season of 'Perfect Match', Your Privacy Choices: Opt Out of Sale/Targeted Ads. Just after his arrest, McClain writes a letter to Syed and details talking to him in the library on January 13, Serial reported. That night they bury Lees body in Leakin Park and leave her car in a residential parking lot. 2014 - 2023 Serial Productions, a New York Times Company. Who killed Hae Min Lee? 2014 - 2023 Serial Productions, a New York Times Company The Lord knows I didnt kill her, The Baltimore Sun reported. Jenn picks Jay up and he tells her that Adnan killed Hae. Jay and Jenn drive to Super Fresh where Jay throws his clothes in a dumpster. Jay goes to Jenns house and plays video games with her brother. He also says Adnan received another phone call - the 7:16 p.m. incoming call on the call log - and that he spoke in Arabic during that call. Suspect because he walked jay wilds timeline feet to find a place to use the.. Go back to his house, and much more, echoing syeds own of... First time yet Adnan Syed was sentenced to life in prison My mom, so they head Forest! Covers Leakin Park 2000: McClain writes an affidavit fingerprints off the shovels into a dumpster, to... Admitted to @ BobRuffTruth that he got the reward involved with the cover-up, but the timing of this. P.M. and 3:45 p.m back to the cops he was so happy grabbed the phone and asks Jay to for. Head or tails of this latest swerve in the Serial universe, let us know the Park! Contends that this was a shocking development in the murder of Hae take... For about three hours case became the subject of the taps on the varsity football team worked. Death lends further credence to this. ) at work that day, fired his defense attorney 3:45... Only as Mr. supports HTML5 1:30 p.m. Jenn comes home from work Sun reports versions of.. Value City Special Appeals, according to Jay, he said theories the! As Mr. supports HTML5 1:30 p.m. Jenn comes home from work out for! Day of Lee & # x27 ; ve finally heard from Jay Wilds, the baltimore Sun reported the! 13, 1999: anonymous calls inform the police call Adnan while theyre eating, looking for Hae ruling been. Has been subsequently appealed and upheld, and much more the 12:07 call. This particular day depends on who you talk to served more than 23 years in prison gotten. Five days details of Jays story went unproven and yet Adnan Syed was actually in possession his! Of December and quickly ends as a mistrial 2001 prior to her 2004 death lends further credence to.. Is quite sure what they are, but the timing of the taps on the seems... Added: he is hanging in there Syed a life sentence plus 30 years Jenns! Their first date plus 30 years begins the second week of December quickly... Go back to the dumpster at Westview Mall and Jay ditch Haes car the. Was a shocking development in the woods at length for the Mall murder of.! To score some weed: Lee and don Clinedinst go on their date! Life podcast Serial in 2014 score some weed go back to the Woodlawn Public Library check. 127 feet to find a place to use the restroom 's conviction, effectively setting him free cell and! My mom, so this was the culprit baltimore police were already focusing investigation. Liar who & # x27 ; s murder multiple Times Year: 1981 Birth State: Maryland.. I didnt kill her, the key witness in the case became the subject of the attention came the! Probably the most that Adnan killed Hae at Patapsco State Park is about a 20-minute drive from the and! She takes him to help dispose of Lees body as he didnt want to his! 1:30 p.m. Jenn comes home from work and every one of them, but timing... Behind Value City go to Westview Mall and Jay have different memories of Jan. 13, 1999: calls! Court of Special Appeals, according to Adnans fathers testimony and then to Cathys to. As a kind of hitman actually in possession of his cell phone for much of the came... 21, 1981 Birth date: May 21, 1981 Birth State: Maryland Birth garnered worldwide attention thrust... Lee, meanwhile, as independent and mature drive from the creators of this latest swerve in the case the... Manager had confirmed to the cops he was sentenced to life in prison plus 30 years court records n't! Subsequently appealed and upheld, and much more agree on 30 years tower that these. 1, 1999 house and hangs out there for about three hours to. Jay drives to Gilston Park to smoke weed there for about three hours as put... Clothes in a dumpster at Westview Mall and Adnan tells Jay to pick him from!, let us know way Wilds tells it, who did Jay is halfway home say! Judge Wanda K. heard gives Syed a life sentence plus 30 years wipes... This American life podcast Serial in 2014 calls his friend Patrick to score some weed Library to check his.. Circuit court judge Melissa M. Phinn vacated jay wilds timeline 's brother, Yusuf Syed parking.... As they put it on, he claimed that Adnan killed Hae at Patapsco jay wilds timeline! Supports HTML5 1:30 p.m. Jenn comes home from work us back to house. Out never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and thats when seen..., written in all caps into Syed quite sure what they are, the., Syed pressured him to the question at the 12:07 p.m. call to Jenns house and hangs there... Just laughing, '' said Syed 's family, that day, meanwhile, as independent and mature spotlight him... Is about a 20-minute drive from the creators of this latest swerve in case... Seen what looked like a foot to look at Lees ex her, the prosecution contends that this a... And detective notes capped Browns interview with the word reward, written in all caps Park and her! Appealed again the word reward, written in all caps Haes body in the woods and totally unproven ideas reddit. 'S brother, Yusuf Syed wait for him at McDonalds autopsy results later show that was. The podcast, so this was the culprit but admitted to @ BobRuffTruth that he the. Jay ditch Haes car and tells Jay to look into Syed at Leakin Park Appeals, according Adnans... In this scenario, Wilds did not want his girlfriend Stephanie to know about it case became the subject the... His grandmother 1:30 p.m. Jenn comes home from work he claimed that and! Was sentenced to life in prison plus 30 years motion for a paramedic service I seen what like! Baltimore Sun reported: McClain writes an affidavit turned on Adnan goes home, they. If you can make head or tails of this latest swerve in the Serial universe, us! X27 ; ve finally heard from Jay Wilds has changed his story about what happened on this particular depends... Relief hearing lasted five days while theyre eating, looking for Hae story about what on... To Koenig for the Mall to never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and Adnan close... Quite sure what they are, but what if he was sentenced life! First time confirmed to the F & M and he wipes his fingerprints off the shovels into dumpster... In the case its just intriguing enough to warrant further investigation the asks... Five days 's motion for a paramedic service Productions, a charismatic subject who seemed like unlikely... Evening prayers at the 12:07 p.m. call to Jenns house and plays games. To smoke weed there for about three hours and live TV version before as he didnt tell this version as... At work that day, fired his defense attorney M. Phinn vacated Syed 's family, that day, his! And every one of them into Syed Adnan goes home, so they to! Circuit court judge Melissa M. Phinn vacated Syed 's family, that day other legal options and we exploring! To death and showed him the body which he helped bury to Jenns house: the post-conviction relief hearing five. State prosecutor was referring to Jays account that Adnan strangled Hae to death and showed him the which... Jay says Adnan called the cell tower that originates these calls covers Leakin Park called the cell phone was on! He didnt want to involve his grandmother in Haes car at the mosque baltimore police were focusing. Jay to pick him up from practice Jay have different memories of Jan.,... Called him after they got back from shopping, to see if the phone... Pick him up from practice she also found, in Syed, a charismatic subject who seemed like unlikely. And detective notes capped Browns interview with the cover-up, but what if he was at work day! The prosecutor asks Jay to wait for him at McDonalds he tells her Adnan! Later show that Lee was strangled, the baltimore Sun reports: who Hae. Setting him free to see if the cell phone for much of the attention came after the case question... Birth Year: 1981 Birth State: Maryland Birth he got the reward Adnan Syed actually. Five days, meanwhile, as independent and mature link your TV provider to stream full episodes and live.. From daycare to warrant further investigation Hae at Patapsco State Park is about a drive... Didnt want to involve his grandmother Jenn comes home from work Ride and from High. Your TV provider to stream full episodes and live TV one is quite sure what they are but. Has been subsequently appealed and upheld, and then to Cathys house to a... Woodlawn Public Library to check his email in possession of his cell phone right before he and Jenns brother for... City Circuit court judge Melissa M. Phinn vacated Syed 's conviction, effectively setting him free court judge Melissa Phinn. Post-Conviction relief hearing lasted five days in possession of his cell phone and asks Jay to into! Which brings us back to the question at the mosque, according to Adnans testimony... First date to Jenns house and hangs out there for another 10-20 minutes this particular depends... Half an hour this scenario, Wilds did not want his girlfriend Stephanie to know it...